The NHS and government aren’t addressing gender concerns in mental health inpatient care

Dr Andrew McCulloch, Chief Executive of the Mental Health Foundation: 

Yesterday, the Care Quality Commission published the Count Me In report which revealed troubling statistics about the state of mental health inpatient care in the UK.

According to this alarming report only 23% of female and 39% of male mental health inpatients are accommodated in designated single-sex wards, despite it having been government policy since 2005. An astonishing 13% of male and 16% of female mental health inpatients still don’t even have access to designated single sex toilets and bathing facilities.

The privacy, dignity and, in some cases, meeting of cultural or religious needs that same-sex wards give mental health inpatients are essential not only to aid recovery, but to respect their rights as human beings.

Mixed sex wards not only increase stress and anxiety in patients at a time when they are most vulnerable, they also compromise patient safety. For instance, sleeping vulnerable women in the same stressful confines as men with severe mental health problems seems self-evidently unsuitable for all concerned, yet this is exactly what is currently happening with nearly four fifths of female mental health inpatients. It really is shameful.

This unfortunate situation is not the fault of mental health services and especially not of care staff, who do a great job in difficult conditions. It is the result of a systematic failure by NHS bodies and successive governments to deliver on their express pledges to address this issue.

The previous Labour government made a commitment to delivering single sex accommodation for mental health inpatients, but as these figures show, they fundamentally failed to deliver this. The current coalition government has renewed this pledge, but we have yet to hear what steps they will be taking to achieve it .

A lot has been discussed recently about the merits (or otherwise) of the coalition’s proposed NHS reforms, yet here is a reform that could prove as important to the patients concerned as anything else. They need to make delivering it a pressing priority if the NHS is to avoid failing yet another generation of mental health inpatients.

Published 06 April 2011 |
Email Blog


There is 1 comment.

  • I have worked for five years on an acut mental health ward in bury. On a daily basis i have seen first hand how stressed the ward becomes due to same sex admissions. I would particularly like to stress that bi-polar women with sexually inappropriate behaviour has been an issue for the men on the ward. There are two wards and the trust choose to have them as north and south wards depending on the address of the service user. This is a new unit and has individual toileting facilities in each room. Why the trust cannot simply have downstairs for one sex and visa verser i do not know. I love my job and have ideas of what can help each person regarding their mental illness, but time is an issue and the amount of paperwork is unreal. This takes away from communicating effectively with the clients.thank you

    Anonymous 06 April 2011
Add Comment